What a thesis has to do

Three jobs, no exceptions. It has to be contestable, meaning someone could reasonably disagree. It has to be specific, meaning it names what is being claimed about what. And it has to be answerable within the word count, with the evidence available.

Everything else is style. If a sentence fails one of those three tests, the essay will struggle, and no amount of elegant prose will rescue it.

The five-step method

Step 1: Answer the question as plainly as you can. Write a sentence you would say out loud to a friend. It will be clumsy and that is fine.

Step 2: Add the reason. A thesis without a because is an assertion. "Remote work raises productivity" is a claim; "remote work raises productivity because it removes commute fatigue and increases uninterrupted focus time" is an argument.

Step 3: Name the counter-position. What would someone who disagrees say? If you cannot think of one, your claim is probably not contestable, or you have not read enough.

Step 4: Narrow it until it fits. A thesis that requires you to prove everything proves nothing. Cut the scope: one sector, one period, one mechanism.

Step 5: Cut the throat-clearing. Delete "In this essay I will argue that", "It can be said that" and "Throughout history". Start with the claim.

Three examples, weakest to strongest

Weak: "Social media has changed how teenagers communicate." Nobody could disagree, so nothing is being argued. This is a topic sentence pretending to be a thesis.

Better: "Social media has damaged teenagers' ability to hold face-to-face conversations." Contestable, but vague: which platform, which aspect of communication, measured how?

Strong: "Image-based platforms have narrowed teenagers' written communication to short, performance-oriented exchanges, and the effect is most pronounced among 13 to 15 year olds, for whom the audience is least differentiated." Specific, contestable, answerable in 2,500 words, and it tells the reader exactly what evidence is coming.

Where the thesis goes

At the end of the introduction, in almost every discipline. Two exceptions worth knowing: in some humanities essays the thesis emerges over the first two paragraphs rather than in one sentence, and in scientific reports the equivalent is the hypothesis or the stated aim. In both cases the reader should know by the end of the first page what is being claimed.

How to check it before you write

Read your thesis and ask three questions. Could a smart classmate disagree? If no, rewrite. Does every body paragraph connect to it? If not, either the paragraph or the thesis is wrong. Could you state it in one breath? If not, it is two theses.

Then keep it visible while you write. Most essays that drift do so because the thesis was written once and never looked at again.

Revising a thesis after the fact

If you have already written the essay and the thesis no longer fits, change the thesis, not the evidence. The essay is the argument you actually made; the thesis should describe it honestly. A thesis that overclaims relative to your evidence is the most common reason a strong essay gets a mid-band mark.

Related: how to write an essay in 7 steps, and argumentative essays, where the thesis carries the most weight.